Rapid evaluation of the use of pulse oximeters

This study aims to evaluate the use of pulse oximeters (which measure the level of oxygen in the blood) in care homes across England to support the care of residents with COVID-19 and long-term health conditions. The devices are valuable because many people with COVID-19 or illnesses such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and asthma may have dangerously low levels of oxygen in their blood, despite feeling well.

An infographic summarises the study and its key findings.

Pulse oximeters are increasingly used in care homes. This is supported in a variety of ways by the NHS, including supplying pulse oximeters, and providing information about how to use them, and how to respond appropriately when the oximeters reveal danger signs.

This is a collaborative project between BRACE and RSET (a second NIHR HSDR programme rapid evaluation team) with input from NHS England and Improvement (NHSE & I) and from a User Involvement Group.

Key points are available in a report slide deck (PDF) and a blog written by Dr Manni Sidhu sharing the lessons from two independent rapid evaluations of Pulse oximetry in care homes during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Covid Oximetry @Home project

Dr Manni Sidhu talks about the Covid Oximetry @Home project

Transcript

How has this device, called a pulse oximeter, helped staff working in care homes in England save the lives of residents during the COVID 19 pandemic? Over the next couple of minutes, I'll explain how findings from two independent evaluations on the use of pulse oximetry, in care homes in general and as part of a new service called NHS COVID Oximetry at Home (which involves the remote monitoring of patients using the telephone or online app with the support of clinicians), has helped inform policymakers to understand the needs of care homes better.

My name is Manni Sidhu and I'm a Research Fellow working for NIHR-funded BRACE Rapid Evaluation Centre. I've worked with colleagues from the RSET Rapid Service Evaluation Team and Imperial College London. Collectively, we’ve produced a slide deck to share key lessons from our two evaluations. Study One will explore the views of NHS and care home staff about the use of COVID Oximetry to manage the health of residents, and Study Two describes the characteristics of residents on-boarded onto the COVID Oximetry at Home programme and the rates of mortality and hospital admission.

In summary, we found that pulse oximetry was not challenging to use by members of staff, and pulse oximeters were quite easy to use as part of a suite of diagnostic tools to manage the health and wellbeing of residents within care homes. There is a need for further training, and especially when to escalate the care of residents and when to seek NHS help. There is scope for further awareness of the COVID Oximetry at Home programme in the health sector, and of the 29,606 care home residents with a positive COVID-19 test, only 812—that's 2.7 percent—were onboarded onto the COVID Oximetry at Home programme.

Findings from both evaluations have been summarised in the slide deck, which is available from the BRACE, RSET, and Imperial College London websites. More comprehensive findings, both in the form of peer-reviewed publications and reports, will be forthcoming. If you'd like to learn more about these studies or have any questions, please visit our institutional websites. Thank you for listening.

Approach

This rapid evaluation aims to take a snapshot of the situation and provide quick, accurate findings so as to share experiences across the care home sector and inform future NHS support to care homes using pulse oximetry. In the study we try to answer the following research questions:

  • In which particular circumstances are pulse oximeters used in care homes?
  • What helps or hinders the use of pulse oximeters in care homes?
  • How can the NHS best support staff and residents of care homes using pulse oximeters to monitor people’s health?
  • What are the pros and cons of using pulse oximeters in care homes?

The evaluation has two main parts. The first is a survey sent to the manager at each of the approximately 15,000 care homes registered with the Care Quality Commission, which is the organisation responsible for regulating care homes in England. The second part of the study involves researchers interviewing care home managers and staff at a sample of six care homes across England, and also some of the NHS staff (e.g., GPs and community nurses) working with the care homes in supporting residents when they are unwell.

Project team

Co-Principal Investigators

Research team

User Involvement Group

Outputs

National Institute for Health Research, Health Services and Delivery Research stream (NIHR HSDR) published report in Journals Library: Using pulse oximeters in care homes for residents with COVID-19 and other conditions: a rapid mixed-methods evaluation Manbinder Sidhu, Ian Litchfield, Robin Miller, Naomi J Fulop, Barbara Janta, Jamie-Rae Tanner, Giulia Maistrello, Jenny Bousfield, Cecilia Vindrola-Padros, Jon Sussex

Download the key points in the slide deck.

A journal article in EClinical Medicine, March 2022 looks at the impact of remote home monitoring of people with COVID-19 using pulse oximetry: A national population and observational study

A blog written by Dr Manni Sidhu shares the lessons from two independent rapid evaluations of Pulse oximetry in care homes during the COVID-19 pandemic

Project Duration

January 2021 – August 2021