Toxic chemicals caused massive fish deaths

A chemical cocktail of micropollutants amplified the effect of algal toxins causing mass fish mortality on the River Oder in 2022

Dead fish floating on surface of river

Dead fish floating on surface of the Oder

A new scientific study published in Nature Water has shed light on a dangerous type of algae, known as Prymnesium parvum, that has been linked to large-scale fish deaths in rivers, lakes, and commercial fish farms worldwide.

The study lead by a team of scientists coordinated by the Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ) with researchers from the Leibniz-Institute of Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries (IGB), the University of Birmingham and the University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna (Vetmeduni) offers insights into how these harmful algae and their toxins acted together with mixtures of micropollutants during the devastating fish kill in the Oder River in August 2022.

These findings underscore the urgent need for more research to understand how these algae affect both aquatic ecosystems and human health.

The findings of this study highlight the environmental dangers posed by blooms of Prymnesium parvum. which can lead to massive fish kills and disrupt the health of aquatic ecosystems. Toxic algal blooms have become a seasonal reality for many countries, including the UK and USA, impacting drinking water supplies and bathing waters.

Professor Luisa Orsini - University of Birmingham

The research aimed to understand the role of Prymnesium parvum in its broader impact on the environment and human health. Scientists hypothesized that the toxins produced by these algae, called prymnesins, would potentially interact with organic micropollutants that are also found to be present in the water samples collected during the fish kill event and could potentially pose additional risk to nontarget organisms and human water use. "The aim of the study was to find out which micropollutants are in the River Oder, how they affect aquatic organisms in the river and what threat the cocktail of algal toxins and micropollutants could pose to humans," says Prof Dr Beate Escher, lead author and environmental toxicologist at the UFZ.

The international research team used a multifaceted scientific approach on what was an opportunistic sampling of the fish kill event. Water sample analysis measured the levels of prymnesins and other pollutants in water samples from the Oder River. Toxicity testing was used to evaluate the toxic effects of the algae on traditional aquatic species, including algae, daphnids, fish embryos, and human neuronal cell lines, whilst a mixture model was performed for aquatic toxicity and in vitro neurotoxicity.Finally, researchers calculated risk levels for aquatic life, finding that the toxins significantly exceeded safe thresholds.

The resulting key findings revealed high levels of prymnesins in the Oder River during the fish kill event. This evidence strongly suggests that these toxins were the main cause of fish deaths, more so than other pollutants found in the water. The research demonstrated that micropollutants detected during the fish kill event are aquatic organisms, posing a serious threat to the health of aquatic ecosystems. The study also raised concerns about the possible health risks prymnesins could pose to humans as high in vitro neurotoxicity. Lastly, the chemical cocktail of hundreds of organic micropollutants acted together with prymnesins to cause neurotoxicity in vitro.

Professor Luisa Orsini from the University of Birmingham says the warmer temperatures and extreme weather events being experienced globally caused by climate change makes such blooms an even greater risk to inland and marine waters and the human population. She said: “The findings of this study highlight the environmental dangers posed by blooms of Prymnesium parvum. which can lead to massive fish kills and disrupt the health of aquatic ecosystems. Toxic algal blooms have become a seasonal reality for many countries, including the UK and USA, impacting drinking water supplies and bathing waters."

Dr Xiaojing Li, also from the University of Birmingham, stressed the key role that sentinel species, such as daphnids (commonly known as waterfleas), can play in predicting the risk of pollutants to humans and the environment. She said: “Daphnia is commonly used in environmental studies to help scientists quickly identify harmful chemicals in water that can affect other aquatic life. As such it acts like an early warning system for water pollution.”

The study emphasizes the need for more research on the effects of prymnesins on human health, particularly regarding the safety of drinking water and recreational water use. The research calls for improved monitoring and management strategies to reduce the impact of harmful algal blooms, safeguard aquatic life, and ensure public safety.

Notes for editors

For more information, please contact University of Birmingham Press Office or +44 (0)121 414 2772.

The University of Birmingham is ranked amongst the world’s top 100 institutions. Its work brings people from across the world to Birmingham, including researchers, teachers and more than 8,000 international students from over 150 countries.